Author: MyBachelorFantasy

Points – Peter Episode # 12 Finale Part 2

And we have another format breaking finale! Props to Hannah Ann for her well rehearsed yet powerful breakup monologue; this is the most likeable she’s been all season. Also props to Madison for standing up to Peter’s helicopter mom. I think Peter realized his best play here was to admit he made “101 mistakes as the Bachelor” and that he’s “far from perfect”, so I was ok with his performance at the live show. I still say Peter and Hannah B are perfect for eachother – time will tell!

I’d like to say Barb is the biggest loser of this season, but she currently has 98K Instagram followers. She’s clearly not here for the #rightreasons. But I think most of us can agree that being combative on live television towards your son who you supposedly love more than anything is totally worth the fame.

Notes on scoring:

  1. Sincere apologies for not getting the points for the rose ceremony during Women Tell All out to you last week. This week’s spreadsheet and the totals below include points for the last 3 episodes
  2. I agonized on whether or not to award the 150 points to Madison for “Pulling a Mesnick (Coming in 2nd, then being chosen by the Bachelor(ette) after 1st place contestant is dumped)“. It’s pretty unclear whether or not Peter “chose” Madison after dumping Hannah Ann. When Chis asked if they were going to give this thing a real shot, Peter’s response was non-convincing. I think this highlights an opportunity to remove some of the ambiguity in the verbiage of the point categories, which I’ll work on for next season. I did award Madison the 150 points. However, polling shows that opions are very mixed on this one, so just subtract 150 points from Madison if you don’t want to count it
  3. I listened over and over to the Hannah Ann/Peter proposal scene and though she did say “I get to love you forever”, she never directly expressed love to Peter per the rigid guidelines of my love categories so no points here. Similarly, Peter said many times during the live show that he loves Madison, but he never said it directly to Madison, so not counting it.

It’s been such an entertaining season! Thanks for following along with me and helping me to feel that the excessive analysis I do on this show isn’t for nothing. Check back in a couple of months for bachelorette points. I’m considering starting a mailing list so I can alert you when the points have been posted each week. This way you don’t have to check the site 10 times a day while you wait. Stay on the lookout for that.

Cheers!

My Bachelor Fantasy Scoring Template- Peter Episode #12

Hannah Ann 270
Receiving a rose 25
Proposing or being proposed to 75
Receiving the final rose 100
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Being told “I love you” by the bachelor(ette) 35
Madison 150
Pulling a Mesnick (Coming in 2nd, then being chosen by the Bachelor(ette) after 1st place contestant is dumped) 150
Contestant Episode #10 Episode #11 Episode #12 Grand Total
Alayah 0 0 0 210
Alexa 0 0 0 45
Avonlea 0 0 0 0
Courtney 0 0 0 10
Deandra 0 0 0 100
Eunice 0 0 0 0
Hannah Ann 25 115 270 1165
Hannah B 0 0 0 50
Jade 0 0 0 0
Jasmine 0 0 0 35
Jenna 0 0 0 0
Katrina 0 0 0 0
Kelley 0 0 0 330
Kelsey 0 0 0 565
Kiarra 0 0 0 70
Kylie 0 0 0 0
Lauren 0 0 0 10
Lexi 0 0 0 170
Madison 30 185 150 960
Maurissa 0 0 0 0
Megan 0 0 0 0
Mykenna 0 0 0 270
Natasha 0 0 0 255
Payton 0 0 0 10
Sarah 0 0 0 35
Savannah 0 0 0 80
Shiann 0 0 0 155
Sydney 0 0 0 315
Tammy 0 0 0 265
Victoria F 20 0 0 845
Victoria P 0 0 0 360

Points – Peter Episode #11 Finale Part 1

Hey Bach fans! See below for points for part one of Peter’s finale! The spreadsheet and totals will be included with the final post for finale part 2.

Hannah Ann 115
Attending One on One 25
Meeting the bachelor(ette)’s family/friends 20
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Saying “I love you” to the Bachelor(ette) 35
Madison 185
Attending One on One 25
Riding in helicopter/private jet 10
Meeting the bachelor(ette)’s family/friends 20
Discussing sex/intimacy with bachelor(ette) 20
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Leaving show on own accord 40
Saying “I love you” to the Bachelor(ette) 35

 

Points – Peter Epside #9

Oh fantasy suites! What a heavily produced and incredibly uncomfortable episode.

Theory: Why does Victoria F seem so outraged at Madison? Perhaps Peter didn’t sleep with her and Victoria blames Madison? Is there any possible way Peter brought Victoria and her baby voice all the way to fantasy suites way and didn’t sleep with her? Hannah Ann seemed less outraged at Madison and much more disheveled after her date so it seems she had better results. Who knows!

Note on love points for Victoria F: she definitely told peter she was in love with him (25 points). But I’m pretty certain she said “I love you” to Peter in a terrifying babiest of baby voice as they were getting out of bed, so I awarded her the higher 35 points for saying I love you.

See below for this week’s points. Can’t wait to learn about his unspoilable ending!

Next week, I will not be scoring the reunion portion of Women Tell All. If they show any conclusion to the fantasy suite episode, rose ceremony, or typical bachelor programming, I will score that as usual. But the typical women tell all content will not be scored.

My Bachelor Fantasy Scoring Template- Peter Episode #9

Hannah Ann 160
Attending One on One 25
Going to fantasy suite 75
Discussing sex/intimacy with bachelor(ette) 20
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Saying “I’m in love with you” to the Bachelor(ette) 25
Madison 100
Attending One on One 25
Being attached to a harness 10
Saying he/she has never felt this way about anyone before 10
Discussing sex/intimacy with bachelor(ette) 20
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Victoria F 195
Attending One on One 25
Going to fantasy suite 75
Riding in helicopter/private jet 10
Saying he/she has never felt this way about anyone before 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Saying “I’m in love with you” to the Bachelor(ette) 25
Saying “I love you” to the Bachelor(ette) 35
Contestant Episode #9 Grand Total
Alayah 0 210
Alexa 0 45
Avonlea 0 0
Courtney 0 10
Deandra 0 100
Eunice 0 0
Hannah Ann 160 755
Hannah B 0 50
Jade 0 0
Jasmine 0 35
Jenna 0 0
Katrina 0 0
Kelley 0 330
Kelsey 0 565
Kiarra 0 70
Kylie 0 0
Lauren 0 10
Lexi 0 170
Madison 100 595
Maurissa 0 0
Megan 0 0
Mykenna 0 270
Natasha 0 255
Payton 0 10
Sarah 0 35
Savannah 0 80
Shiann 0 155
Sydney 0 315
Tammy 0 265
Victoria F 195 825
Victoria P 0 360

Points – Peter Episode #8

What a week! This week showed us that though Peter isn’t the most athletic Bachelor we’ve ever had, boy does he love to fight.

Victoria F Crazy

There was a lot of love being thrown around this episode. The points system currently only awards points if Peter says “I love you” to a constant (not the camera). So none of the women got credit for any professions of love from Peter this week. This is structured to favor the last woman standing, as the lead typically only says “I love you” to the final contestant. Feel free to score as your league prefers! If you’d like to score a different way, here are some quotes from Peter to help you:

To Madison: “I’m falling head over heels in love with you”

To camera: “I love Madison”

To Hannah Ann: “I can honestly say that I am falling in love with you”

See below for this week’s points!

My Bachelor Fantasy Scoring Template- Peter Episode #8

Hannah Ann 170
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Going on hometown date 50
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Saying “I love you” to the Bachelor(ette) 35
Kelsey 115
Attending One on One 25
Going on hometown date 50
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Saying “I’m in love with you” to the Bachelor(ette) 25
Madison 115
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Going on hometown date 50
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Victoria F 170
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Being called last during rose ceremony 5
Going on hometown date 50
Attending a concert 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Saying “I’m falling for you” or “I’m falling in love with you” to Bachelor(ette) (May include “I think I’m..”) 20
Contestant Episode #8 Grand Total
Alayah 0 210
Alexa 0 45
Avonlea 0 0
Courtney 0 10
Deandra 0 100
Eunice 0 0
Hannah Ann 170 595
Hannah B 0 50
Jade 0 0
Jasmine 0 35
Jenna 0 0
Katrina 0 0
Kelley 0 330
Kelsey 115 565
Kiarra 0 70
Kylie 0 0
Lauren 0 10
Lexi 0 170
Madison 115 495
Maurissa 0 0
Megan 0 0
Mykenna 0 270
Natasha 0 255
Payton 0 10
Sarah 0 35
Savannah 0 80
Shiann 0 155
Sydney 0 315
Tammy 0 265
Victoria F 170 630
Victoria P 0 360

Points – Peter Episode #7

Hometowns are right around the corner! This sneaks up every season. I’d like to applaud Natasha and Kelley for being the two girls who were sent home this week but NOT being the two girls who earned points for crying. Main takeaway from the night: If I were Peter I would have taken an Arie approach to Victoria F

The Bachelor Krystal Last Fight

My opinion is that of the girls remaining, Hannah B is clearly the best choice for Peter.

See below for this week’s points!

My Bachelor Fantasy Scoring Template- Peter Episode #7

Hannah Ann 70
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Kelley 25
Attending group date 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Kelsey 65
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Madison 85
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Attending a concert 10
Riding on boat 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Natasha 50
Attending One on One 25
Attending a concert 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Victoria F 70
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Contestant Episode #7 Grand Total
Alayah 0 210
Alexa 0 45
Avonlea 0 0
Courtney 0 10
Deandra 0 100
Eunice 0 0
Hannah Ann 70 425
Hannah B 0 50
Jade 0 0
Jasmine 0 35
Jenna 0 0
Katrina 0 0
Kelley 25 330
Kelsey 65 450
Kiarra 0 70
Kylie 0 0
Lauren 0 10
Lexi 0 170
Madison 85 380
Maurissa 0 0
Megan 0 0
Mykenna 0 270
Natasha 50 255
Payton 0 10
Sarah 0 35
Savannah 0 80
Shiann 0 155
Sydney 0 315
Tammy 0 265
Victoria F 70 460
Victoria P 0 360

Points – Peter Episode #6

Here are points for Wednesday’s episode. In my opinion, the most controversial call here is whether or not Victoria P left on her own accord. Peter technically didn’t ask her to leave, but I think it’s safe to say he surely would have had she not taken the reins. Also, when he tells the rest of the girls he says he “just sent Victoria P home”. So in the below I am not awarding points for leaving on her own accord. Feel free to score for your league as you see fit.

P.S. we’re already down to the final six! One normal episode left before my favorite part: hometowns. This point in the season always really sneaks up : )

See below for this week’s points!

My Bachelor Fantasy Scoring Template- Peter Episode #6

Hannah Ann 115
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Attending a concert 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Saying “I’m falling for you” or “I’m falling in love with you” to Bachelor(ette) (May include “I think I’m..”) 20
Kelley 55
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose 25
Being called last during rose ceremony 5
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Kelsey 50
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Madison 75
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose 25
Receiving group date rose (in addition to regular rose points) 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Mykenna 90
Attending group date 10
Attending Two on One 30
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Talking shit about another contestant to Bachelor(ette) 15
Natasha 50
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Sydney 35
Attending group date 10
Saying he/she has never felt this way about anyone before 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Tammy 55
Attending group date 10
Attending Two on One 30
Talking shit about another contestant to Bachelor(ette) 15
Victoria F 95
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Riding a horse 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Victoria P 30
Attending group date 10
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Contestant Episode #5 Episode #6 Grand Total
Alayah 20 0 210
Alexa 0 0 45
Avonlea 0 0 0
Courtney 0 0 10
Deandra 20 0 100
Eunice 0 0 0
Hannah Ann 100 115 355
Hannah B 0 0 50
Jade 0 0 0
Jasmine 0 0 35
Jenna 0 0 0
Katrina 0 0 0
Kelley 95 55 305
Kelsey 120 50 385
Kiarra 0 0 70
Kylie 0 0 0
Lauren 0 0 10
Lexi 70 0 170
Madison 60 75 295
Maurissa 0 0 0
Megan 0 0 0
Mykenna 60 90 270
Natasha 60 50 205
Payton 0 0 10
Sarah 0 0 35
Savannah 0 0 80
Shiann 55 0 155
Sydney 105 35 315
Tammy 100 55 265
Victoria F 60 95 390
Victoria P 95 30 360

Points – Peter Episode #5

Hey friends! I’m still in shock that they gave us a 3-hour episode with no warning! 5 hours of bachelor programming this week was a lot to score so if you seen any blatant misses please leave a comment. On the more subjective categories please score as you see fit. There will be a separate post for Wednesday’s episode #6.

See below for this week’s points (Monday only):

My Bachelor Fantasy Scoring Template- Peter Episode #5

Alayah 20
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Deandra 20
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Hannah Ann 100
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Receiving a rose (2nd ceremony) 25
Receiving group date rose (in addition to regular rose points) 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Kelley 95
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Receiving a rose (during 1:1 Date) 25
Hot tubbing 5
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Kelsey 120
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (2nd ceremony) 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Appearing drunk 15
Talking shit about another contestant to Bachelor(ette) 15
Saying “I’m falling for you” or “I’m falling in love with you” to Bachelor(ette) (May include “I think I’m..”) 20
Lexi 70
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Madison 60
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Receiving a rose (2nd ceremony) 25
Mykenna 60
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Receiving a rose (2nd ceremony) 25
Natasha 60
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Receiving a rose (2nd ceremony) 25
Shiann 55
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Sydney 105
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Receiving a rose (1:1 date) 25
Hot tubbing 5
Riding in helicopter/private jet 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Tammy 100
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Receiving a rose (2nd ceremony) 25
Being called last during rose ceremony (1st) 5
Being called last during rose ceremony (2nd) 5
Mentioning a deceased loved one 15
Talking shit about another contestant to Bachelor(ette) 15
Victoria F 60
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (2nd ceremony) 25
Winning or being part of winning team on group date 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Victoria P 95
Attending group date 10
Receiving a rose (1st ceremony) 25
Receiving a rose (2nd ceremony) 25
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Contestant Episode #5 Grand Total
Alayah 20 210
Alexa 0 45
Avonlea 0 0
Courtney 0 10
Deandra 20 100
Eunice 0 0
Hannah Ann 100 240
Hannah B 0 50
Jade 0 0
Jasmine 0 35
Jenna 0 0
Katrina 0 0
Kelley 95 250
Kelsey 120 335
Kiarra 0 70
Kylie 0 0
Lauren 0 10
Lexi 70 170
Madison 60 220
Maurissa 0 0
Megan 0 0
Mykenna 60 180
Natasha 60 155
Payton 0 10
Sarah 0 35
Savannah 0 80
Shiann 55 155
Sydney 105 280
Tammy 100 210
Victoria F 60 295
Victoria P 95 330

Points – Peter Episode #4

Have we ever seen a group date that left the girls so covered in bruises? Good work, ABC. Nothing like futile physical contact to bring the claws out.

Since they left us with a To Be Continued… we’ll be back to having timing differences for rose points. Those who got roses on dates will be awarded points this week, but those who receive a rose during the rose ceremony will receive rose points next week — meaning they could possibly be getting rose points x2 in Episode #5.

See below for points spreadsheet:

My Bachelor Fantasy Scoring Template- Peter Episode #4

Episode #4 Points by Contestant

Alayah 85
Receiving a rose 25
Receiving group date rose (in addition to regular rose points) 25
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Talking shit about another contestant to Bachelor(ette) 15
Deandra 10
Attending group date 10
Hannah Ann 10
Attending group date 10
Kelley 10
Attending group date 10
Kiarra 10
Attending group date 10
Lexi 10
Attending group date 10
Madison 10
Attending group date 10
Kelsey 105
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Attending a concert 10
Saying he/she has never felt this way about anyone before 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Mykenna 10
Attending group date 10
Natasha 10
Attending group date 10
Savannah 10
Attending group date 10
Shiann 10
Attending group date 10
Sydney 10
Attending group date 10
Tammy 10
Attending group date 10
Victoria F 105
Attending One on One 25
Receiving a rose 25
Attending a concert 10
Riding in helicopter/private jet 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Victoria P 60
Attending group date 10
Kissing the bachelor(ette) (on the lips) 15
Crying (must see tears fall from eyes or obvious crying) 20
Talking shit about another contestant to Bachelor(ette) 15
Contestant Episode #4 Grand Total
Alayah 85 190
Alexa 0 45
Avonlea 0 0
Courtney 0 10
Deandra 10 80
Eunice 0 0
Hannah Ann 10 140
Hannah B 0 50
Jade 0 0
Jasmine 0 35
Jenna 0 0
Katrina 0 0
Kelley 10 155
Kelsey 105 215
Kiarra 10 70
Kylie 0 0
Lauren 0 10
Lexi 10 100
Madison 10 160
Maurissa 0 0
Megan 0 0
Mykenna 10 120
Natasha 10 95
Payton 0 10
Sarah 0 35
Savannah 10 80
Shiann 10 100
Sydney 10 175
Tammy 10 110
Victoria F 105 235
Victoria P 60 235

 

Points – Peter Episode #3

So much new vocabulary gained from this episode! My personal favorite is the new and improved pronunciation of lingerie.

See below for a snapshot of the points and the scoring spreadsheet. Lots of crying this episode, but I believe I saw legitimate moisture for all contestants who were awarded crying points.

My Bachelor Fantasy Scoring Template- Peter Episode #3

Contestant Episode #3 Grand Total
Alayah 70 105
Alexa 0 45
Avonlea 0 0
Courtney 0 10
Deandra 25 70
Eunice 0 0
Hannah Ann 45 130
Hannah B 0 50
Jade 0 0
Jasmine 0 35
Jenna 0 0
Katrina 0 0
Kelley 50 145
Kelsey 40 110
Kiarra 35 60
Kylie 0 0
Lauren 0 10
Lexi 40 90
Madison 40 150
Maurissa 0 0
Megan 0 0
Mykenna 50 110
Natasha 40 85
Payton 0 10
Sarah 10 35
Savannah 35 70
Shiann 35 90
Sydney 90 165
Tammy 50 100
Victoria F 0 130
Victoria P 125 175